Reg A vs. Reg D

Understanding the Key Differences in Private Market Offerings

When it comes to raising capital in the private markets, businesses have a variety of tools at their disposal. Two popular regulations under the Securities Act of 1933, Regulation A (Reg A) and Regulation D (Reg D), offer unique opportunities for companies to secure funding while remaining compliant with securities laws. While both serve as pathways for raising capital, they cater to different types of businesses, investors, and fundraising goals.

In this article, we’ll dive into the specifics of Reg A and Reg D, compare their features, and help you determine which might be the best fit for your business. Let’s break it all down.

What Is Reg A?

Regulation A, often referred to as a “mini-IPO,” allows companies to raise money from the general public, including non-accredited investors. Essentially, it opens the door for smaller companies to access public capital markets without the rigorous requirements of a traditional IPO. Reg A comes in two tiers:

Tier 1: Companies can raise up to $20 million in a 12-month period. There are no specific investment limits for individual investors, but offerings require approval from securities regulators in each state where the securities are sold.
Tier 2: Companies can raise up to $75 million in a 12-month period. Unlike Tier 1, Tier 2 offerings are exempt from state-level review, which can make the process faster. However, there are limits on how much non-accredited investors can invest, typically 10% of their annual income or net worth.

Key Features of Reg A:

• Open to both accredited and non-accredited investors.
• Requires a public offering statement filed with the SEC.
• Securities can often be freely traded after the offering.
• More accessible for smaller companies looking to raise significant capital.

What Is Reg D?

Regulation D provides exemptions for companies to raise capital without the need for a full SEC registration. It’s primarily aimed at accredited investors and is widely used by startups, venture capital funds, and private equity firms.

Reg D includes several exemptions, but the most commonly used are Rule 506(b) and Rule 506(c):

Rule 506(b): Allows businesses to raise an unlimited amount of capital from up to 35 non-accredited investors, as long as they are “sophisticated” (i.e., have sufficient knowledge and experience to evaluate the investment). However, businesses cannot publicly solicit or advertise the offering.
Rule 506(c): Permits general solicitation and advertising but limits participation to accredited investors only. Issuers must take reasonable steps to verify the accreditation of investors.

Key Features of Reg D:

• Often faster and less expensive than Reg A due to fewer disclosure requirements.
• Accredited investor focus simplifies compliance and reduces investor limits.
• Securities are typically restricted and can’t be freely traded.

Reg A vs. Reg D: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Reg A	Reg D
Investor Eligibility	Both accredited and non-accredited	Mostly accredited (with exceptions)
Offering Limit	Tier 1: $20M; Tier 2: $75M	Unlimited
General Solicitation	Allowed	Only under Rule 506(c)
SEC Filing Requirements	Required	Minimal
State Review	Tier 1: Required; Tier 2: Exempt	Not required
Trading Restrictions	Freely tradeable (Reg A+)	Restricted securities
Cost & Complexity	Moderate to high	Low to moderate

Advantages of Reg A

Wider Investor Pool: Reg A allows non-accredited investors to participate, opening the door to a much larger audience. This is particularly valuable for consumer-facing businesses looking to build a community of brand advocates who are also investors.
Public Perception: By allowing the public to invest, Reg A often doubles as a marketing tool. A Reg A offering can create buzz around a company’s brand, enhancing visibility.
Tradable Securities: With Reg A, investors can often trade their securities without restrictions, making it a more liquid investment compared to Reg D.
Scalable Fundraising: The tiered structure provides flexibility for companies at different stages of growth.

Advantages of Reg D

Simplicity and Speed: Reg D offerings are generally quicker and less costly to launch compared to Reg A. The reduced disclosure requirements make it an attractive option for startups and early-stage companies.
Privacy: Unlike Reg A, which requires a public filing, Reg D offerings can often be conducted with minimal public disclosure, keeping company details private.
Unlimited Capital Potential: There are no caps on the amount of money a company can raise under Reg D, making it ideal for larger-scale funding needs.
Established Investor Base: Focusing on accredited investors means dealing with individuals or institutions familiar with investment risks, reducing the likelihood of disputes.

Choosing Between Reg A and Reg D

The choice between Reg A and Reg D depends on several factors, including your fundraising goals, target audience, and the stage of your business.

When to Choose Reg A:

• You want to tap into a broader investor pool, including the general public.
• Building brand visibility is a priority.
• You’re prepared to handle more extensive SEC filings and compliance requirements.
• Your business has consumer appeal or a strong public following.

When to Choose Reg D:

• Speed and cost-efficiency are critical.
• You have an existing network of accredited investors.
• Maintaining privacy is important for your business strategy.
• You’re seeking to raise large amounts of capital without offering public access.

Key Considerations

Compliance Costs: Reg A offerings, particularly Tier 2, can involve significant legal and administrative costs. Reg D is generally more cost-effective.
Investor Relations: Managing a larger group of non-accredited investors under Reg A can be more complex than working with accredited investors under Reg D.
Market Liquidity: If your investors prioritize liquidity, Reg A’s tradeable securities might be more appealing than Reg D’s restricted ones.
Long-Term Goals: Consider how the choice aligns with your future fundraising plans. For instance, Reg A can serve as a stepping stone to a full IPO.

Real-World Examples

A Consumer-Focused Startup: A food delivery app looking to build brand loyalty and raise $15 million might opt for Reg A to involve its customer base in the investment process.
A Tech Venture Fund: A venture capital firm raising $100 million for a new fund would likely use Reg D to streamline the process and focus on accredited investors.

Conclusion

Both Reg A and Reg D have their strengths and are valuable tools for businesses looking to raise capital. The right choice depends on your company’s needs, the type of investors you’re targeting, and how you envision the fundraising process fitting into your broader business strategy.

If you’re still unsure which regulation is right for your business, consult with legal and financial advisors who specialize in securities offerings. With the right guidance, you can navigate these regulatory frameworks and secure the capital you need to grow.

Whether you’re building the next unicorn or looking to engage your loyal customer base, understanding the nuances of Reg A and Reg D is a critical first step in making the most of the private markets.

Back ↵